Wikipedia:GLAM/BHL/2018 Women Scientific Illustrators
Main Page | Resources | Tasks | Outcomes | Partners | Event Archive | About |
Introduction
This is a project created by me, Ambrosia10 (talk), in January 2018, to improve data on illustrators found in the digitized content of the Biodiversity Heritage Library (BHL). I am aiming to add to and improve items on illustrators in Wikidata, add illustrations and improve the data relating to them in Wikimedia Commons, and to create or improve Wikipedia articles on the artists themselves. I am particularly interested in improving knowledge of, and access to, art by women scientific illustrators.
This project is an extension of my volunteer work with the Biodiversity Heritage Library and the collatoration I am undertaking with an independent researcher who also volunteers for BHL and who also is interested in women scientific illustrators and their work.
Workflow
- Find an illustrator and undertake basic research. I'm using my Artists & Scientific Illustrators spreadsheet as a starting point in this process.
- Check if a Wikidata item on illustrator exists. If not, create one. Example: Clarissa Munger Badger (Q20769459)
- If Wikidata item does exist, check that the Stuttgart Database of Scientific Illustrators identifier is linked as well as any BHL creator identifier. Discover and add to Wikidata item the VIAF identifier for the illustrator if lacking. Ensure other identifiers mentioned in the VIAF entry, such as the Library of Congress Name Authority File identifier, have also been added to the illustrator's wikidata item. Examples: Stuttgart Database of Scientific Illustrators, BHL VIAF
- Search Wikimedia Commons for the artist category and creator page. If present, ensure they are linked to the artist's Wikidata item. If not present, create them where needed. This may need to wait until the Pattypan spreadsheet for bulk upload of images is complete and awaiting use.
- Search Wikimedia Commons for images by the artist. User:Fae has been uploading thousands of BHL images so ensure that not just the name of the artist but also the titles of the books in which their works are featured are also searched for. See: Commons:Biodiversity Heritage Library for Fae's BHL project page
- If images exist, check whether they need to have the artist's category added to them. If artist has drawn all images in a book or article check that artist category is attached to category page for that work. For images in bulk, consider the use of appending the category markup via Help:VisualFileChange.js.
- Ensure that Wikimedia Commons Creator template markup is added to each illustration. There is no current bulk method for this. Individually edit the markup of each image. Example: Creator:Clarissa Munger Badger
- If images are lacking in Wikimedia Commons, start spreadsheet for bulk upload of images via Pattypan. Ensure that Creator template markup and artist category markup as well as book category markup are added to this spreadsheet. Use BHL permanent page identifier (DOI) for source of image. Prior to uploading the images double check that the appropriate categories and creator page have been created. Example: Category:Clarissa Munger Badger. Categories are hierarchical, so tag publication with creator category. Add institutional template. Examples: Template:Biodiversity Heritage Library
- Check Wikidata to see if the book or scientific article has a Wikidata item. If not, create one. Example: Floral belles from the green-house and garden (Q47097245) Add Wikimedia Commons category. Example Category:Floral belles from the green-house and garden
- If a book or scientific article item exists, ensure that the Wikimedia Commons category and the illustrator are added to the Wikidata item. Also ensure that the BHL DOI for the title is added, if it exists. Example: doi:10.5962/bhl.title.132919
Links, identifiers, templates, tools
- Biodiversity Heritage Library (BHL) – link: Biodiversity Heritage Library
- Wikidata – link: Wikidata
- Wikimedia Commons – link: Wikimedia Commons
- Artists & Scientific Illustrators spreadsheet
- Stuttgart Database of Scientific Illustrators ID (P2349) – link: Stuttgart Database of Scientific Illustrators identifier
- VIAF – link: VIAF
- DOI
- BHL creator ID (P4081)
- BHL page ID (P687)
- BHL bibliography ID (P4327)
- Pattypan – bulk upload tool
- Help:VisualFileChange.js
- Template:Creator
- Template:Institution
- Template:Book
- Template:Artwork
- Template:Photograph
- Other Category:Infobox templates, i.e., Template:Biohist
Work completed
Publication citation | Publication Wikidata item | Publication Commons category | Artist name | Artist Wikidata item | Artist Commons Category |
---|---|---|---|---|---|
Badger, C. M. (1867). Floral Belles from the Green-house and Garden. New York: C. Scribner & Co. doi:10.5962/bhl.title.132919. | Q47097245 | Floral belles from the green-house and garden | Clarissa Munger Badger | Q20769459 | Clarissa Munger Badger |
Featon, E. H.; Featon, S. A. (1889). Art album of New Zealand flora. Wellington: Bock & Cousins. doi:10.5962/bhl.title.24349. | Q47102287 | Art album of New Zealand flora | Sarah Featon | Q7422296 | Sarah Featon |
Cheeseman, T. F. (1914). Illustrations of the New Zealand flora. Wellington: John Mackay. doi:10.5962/bhl.title.12029. | Q47133248 | Matilda Smith | Q3299110 | Matilda Smith | |
Hemsley, William Botting (1885). "Report on the scientific results of the voyage of H.M.S. Challenger during the years 1873-76. Botany.". Report on the scientific results of the voyage of H.M.S. Challenger during the years 1873-76. Botany Vol. 1 – via Biodiversity Heritage Library. | Q47158174 | Report on the scientific results of the voyage of H.M.S. Challenger during the years 1873-76. Botany - Vol. 1. | Matilda Smith, Walter Hood Fitch, William Mitten | Q3299110 Q1102060 Q2918015 | Matilda Smith Walter Hood Fitch William Mitten |
Balfour, Isaac Bayley (1888). "Botany of Socotra". Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh. 31 – via Biodiversity Heritage Library. | Q20013586 | Botany of Socotra | Matilda Smith, Harriet Anne Hooker Thiselton-Dyer, John Nugent Fitch | Q3299110 Q15995730 Q12057765 | Matilda Smith Harriet Anne Thiselton-Dyer John Nugent Fitch |
Discussion on workflow, issues and outcomes
First attempt at workflow: Clarissa Munger Badger – Floral Belles from the Green-house and Garden
I used illustrations by Clarissa Munger Badger in Floral Belles from the Green-house and Garden as a trial image set. This set was manageable for a trial run as it was relatively small and the images were all illustrated by the same artist. This ensured that my first attempt progressing through the workflow was achieved relatively seamlessly. I did discover one challenge. I was unable to use the BHL template for adding images to Wikimedia Commons when using Pattypan. For ease I ended up using the basic "information" template. See this image. Ideally I would like to use the BHL template as shown here; however, creating code for this via Pattypan is currently beyond my coding capabilities.
Sarah Featon - Art Album of New Zealand Flora
I again used Pattypan to upload these images. The main issue was attempting to use the OCR in BHL for the description of the place. I wanted to copy and paste the description. Unfortunately, as is frequently the case, the OCR needed correcting. This slowed the process significantly as a careful eye was needed to ensure species names were correctly spelt. I also didn't add species categories to the images. This felt very much against the grain and I suspect I'll add them in the near future.
I also came across a copyright issue relating to previous uploads of these images. A set of edited images had already been uploaded by Commons:User:Rawpixel. This user appears to be a company that takes images, in this case images illustrated by Sarah Featon, which are in the public domain, they slightly retouch the images and then claim the work as their own. They license it under the CC BY SA 4.0 license. See for example this image. I've added license review markup to these images but this is the second time I've come across images from this user which appear to claim copyright in works in the public domain. The other time was with the work of New Zealand illustrator F. E. Clarke. See this example.
Matilda Smith - Illustrations of the New Zealand Flora
These images have been loaded into Flickr by BHL. I have previously taxotagged those images with both the text and current taxonomy as well as the artist name and viaf number. I would prefer that metadata be uploaded into Wikicommons with the image as I don't want to replicate my efforts. Many of the BHL images in Flickr have been uploaded into Wikicommons by User:Fæ who manages to ensure tags are included in the upload. I am again limited by my lack of coding abilities as I can't work out how to replicate this. I'm therefore leaving these images until they are uploaded into Wikicommons and will interlink them when they are available.
Matilda Smith - Report on the scientific results of the voyage of H.M.S. Challenger during the years 1873-76. Botany Vol. 1.
The Pattypan process was straightforward but the creation of the Wikidata entries for the main report and then the Botany reports and the two volumes challenged my wikidata skills. I also feel I need to upskill my library cataloguing skills as I'm sure more experienced folk with this skill set would find it easier to create appropriate Wikidata items for these volumes. However although they may not be ideal wikidata items they do now exist and have enabled the linking of these illustrations with their illustrators data.
I've got a query about Wikidata and Wikicommons that I can't seem to find an answer to. Looking at the wikidata entry of the subject of an illustration, for example Clematis paniculata, there is a section that links "other sites". I've seen many wikidata entries that link to the Commons gallery page whereas I believe it should be the Commons category page as shown in the example. However I can't find any confirmation that this is recommended.
Matilda Smith - Botany of Socotra.
I'm getting very used to the Pattypan process by now. I've added the text names for the plants in the description but also the current name within the categories of the image. Many of these plants are not illustrated in English wikipedia and these images can be added. They could also be added to Wikidata.
Next steps
I intend to continue to choose candidates from my artists and scientific illustrators spreadsheet to include in this project. There have been occasions where I have found New Zealand botanical illustrations or publications that are not yet or will never be in BHL. If possible I have put in a scanning request attempting to get the publication into BHL. If this is not possible (See for example Martha King) I'll attempt to source the illustrations from another source.
Gallery
- Badger, C. M. (1867). Floral Belles from the Green-house and Garden. New York: C. Scribner & Co. doi:10.5962/bhl.title.132919.
-
Image 0008Image 0008
-
Image 0019Image 0019
-
Image 0023Image 0023
-
Image 0027Image 0027
-
Image 0031Image 0031
-
Image 0035Image 0035
-
Image 0039Image 0039
-
Image 0043Image 0043
-
Image 0047Image 0047
-
Image 0051Image 0051
-
Image 0055Image 0055
-
Image 0059Image 0059
-
Image 0063Image 0063
-
Image 0067Image 0067
-
Image 0071Image 0071
-
Image 0075Image 0075
- Featon, E. H.; Featon, S. A (1889). Art Album of New Zealand Flora. Wellington: Bock & Cousins. doi:10.5962/bhl.title.24349.
-
P1 Image 0015P1 Image 0015
-
P1 Image 0018P1 Image 0018
-
P1 Image 0027P1 Image 0027
-
P1 Image 0030P1 Image 0030
-
P1 Image 0041P1 Image 0041
-
P1 Image 0055P1 Image 0055
-
P1 Image 0065P1 Image 0065
-
P1 Image 0073P1 Image 0073
-
P1 Image 0078P1 Image 0078
-
P1 Image 0085P1 Image 0085
-
P1 Image 0107P1 Image 0107
-
P1 Image 0110P1 Image 0110
-
P1 Image 0120P1 Image 0120
-
P1 Image 0127P1 Image 0127
-
P2 Image 0011P2 Image 0011
-
P2 Image 0021P2 Image 0021
-
P2 Image 0035P2 Image 0035
-
P2 Image 0041P2 Image 0041
-
P2 Image 0049P2 Image 0049
-
P2 Image 0057P2 Image 0057
-
P2 Image 0065P2 Image 0065
-
P2 Image 0071P2 Image 0071
-
P2 Image 0077P2 Image 0077
-
P2 Image 0083P2 Image 0083
-
P2 Image 0089P2 Image 0089
-
P2 Image 0101P2 Image 0101
-
P2 Image 0109P2 Image 0109
- Cheeseman, T. F. (1914). Illustrations of the New Zealand Flora. Wellington: John Mackay. doi:10.5962/bhl.title.12029.
-
File:X
- Hemsley, William Botting (1885). "Report on the Scientific Results of the Voyage of H.M.S. Challenger During the Years 1873-76. Botany". Report on the scientific results of the voyage of H.M.S. Challenger during the years 1873-76. Botany Vol. 1.
-
Image 0235Image 0235
-
Image 0239Image 0239
-
Image 0243Image 0243
-
Image 0247Image 0247
-
Image 0251Image 0251
-
Image 0255Image 0255
-
Image 0259Image 0259
-
Image 0263Image 0263
-
Image 0267Image 0267
-
Image 0271Image 0271
-
Image 0275Image 0275
-
Image 0279Image 0279
-
Image 0283Image 0283
-
Image 0587Image 0587
-
Image 0591Image 0591
-
Image 0595Image 0595
-
Image 0603Image 0603
-
Image 0607Image 0607
-
Image 0611Image 0611
-
Image 0615Image 0615
-
Image 0619Image 0619
-
Image 0623Image 0623
-
Image 0627Image 0627
-
Image 0631Image 0631
-
Image 0635Image 0635
-
Image 0639Image 0639
-
Image 0643Image 0643
-
Image 0647Image 0647
-
Image 0651Image 0651
-
Image 0655Image 0655
-
Image 0659Image 0659
-
Image 0663Image 0663
-
Image 0667Image 0667
-
Image 0671Image 0671
-
Image 0675Image 0675
-
Image 0679Image 0679
-
Image 0683Image 0683
-
Image 0687Image 0687
-
Image 0691Image 0691
-
Image 0695Image 0695
-
Image 0699Image 0699
-
Image 0703Image 0703
-
Image 0707Image 0707
-
Image 0711Image 0711
-
Image 0715Image 0715
-
Image 0719Image 0719
-
Image 0723Image 0723
-
Image 0727Image 0727
-
Image 0731Image 0731
-
Image 0735Image 0735
-
Image 0739Image 0739
-
Image 0743Image 0743
-
Image 1081Image 1081
-
Image 1085Image 1085
-
Image 1089Image 1089
-
Image 1093Image 1093
-
Image 1097Image 1097
-
Image 1101Image 1101
-
Image 1105Image 1105
-
Image 1109Image 1109
-
Image 1113Image 1113
-
Image 1117Image 1117
-
Image 1121Image 1121
-
Image 1125Image 1125
- Balfour, Isaac Bayley (1888). "Botany of Socotra". Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh. 31.
-
Image 0535Image 0535
-
Image 0539Image 0539
-
Image 0543Image 0543
-
Image 0547Image 0547
-
Image 0551Image 0551
-
Image 0555Image 0555
-
Image 0559Image 0559
-
Image 0563Image 0563
-
Image 0567Image 0567
-
Image 0571Image 0571
-
Image 0575Image 0575
-
Image 0579Image 0579
-
Image 0583Image 0583
-
Image 0587Image 0587
-
Image 0591Image 0591
-
Image 0595Image 0595
-
Image 0599Image 0599
-
Image 0603Image 0603
-
Image 0607Image 0607
-
Image 0611Image 0611
-
Image 0615Image 0615
-
Image 0619Image 0619
-
Image 0623Image 0623
-
Image 0627Image 0627
-
Image 0631Image 0631
-
Image 0635Image 0635
-
Image 0639Image 0639
-
Image 0643Image 0643
-
Image 0647Image 0647
-
Image 0651Image 0651
-
Image 0655Image 0655
-
Image 0659Image 0659
-
Image 0663Image 0663
-
Image 0667Image 0667
-
Image 0671Image 0671
-
Image 0675Image 0675
-
Image 0679Image 0679
-
Image 0683Image 0683
-
Image 0687Image 0687
-
Image 0691Image 0691
-
Image 0695Image 0695
-
Image 0699Image 0699
-
Image 0703Image 0703
-
Image 0707Image 0707
-
Image 0711Image 0711
-
Image 0715Image 0715
-
Image 0719Image 0719
-
Image 0723Image 0723
-
Image 0727Image 0727
-
Image 0731Image 0731
-
Image 0735Image 0735
-
Image 0739Image 0739
-
Image 0743Image 0743
-
Image 0747Image 0747
-
Image 0751Image 0751
-
Image 0755Image 0755
-
Image 0759Image 0759
-
Image 0763Image 0763
-
Image 0767Image 0767
-
Image 0771Image 0771
-
Image 0775Image 0775
-
Image 0779Image 0779
-
Image 0783Image 0783
-
Image 0787Image 0787
-
Image 0791Image 0791
-
Image 0795Image 0795
-
Image 0799Image 0799
-
Image 0803Image 0803
-
Image 0807Image 0807
-
Image 0811Image 0811
-
Image 0815Image 0815
-
Image 0819Image 0819
-
Image 0823Image 0823
-
Image 0827Image 0827
-
Image 0831Image 0831
-
Image 0835Image 0835
-
Image 0839Image 0839
-
Image 0843Image 0843
-
Image 0847Image 0847
-
Image 0851Image 0851
-
Image 0855Image 0855
-
Image 0859Image 0859
-
Image 0863Image 0863
-
Image 0867Image 0867
-
Image 0871Image 0871
-
Image 0875Image 0875
-
Image 0879Image 0879
-
Image 0883Image 0883
-
Image 0887Image 0887
-
Image 0891Image 0891
-
Image 0895Image 0895
-
Image 0899Image 0899
-
Image 0903Image 0903
-
Image 0907Image 0907
-
Image 0911Image 0911
-
Image 0915Image 0915
-
Image 0919Image 0919
-
Image 0923Image 0923
-
Image 0927Image 0927
-
Image 0931Image 0931
External links
- Biodiversity Heritage Library